Financial discovery is the fact finding/document gathering part of the divorce process. Financial discovery can be time consuming and may be the most expensive part of a divorce process for a wealthy family. Financial discovery will most likely happen over time. The amount of time depends on whether or not the parties are being cooperative. It is a process, not an event, and requires ongoing document requests until all necessary information is gathered.
For the most part, discovery takes place outside the courtroom, with parties exchanging written information and sitting through face-to-face questioning sessions (called “depositions”). However, if the parties can’t agree on what should be handed over in discovery, a judge may have to resolve the dispute.
The kind of information that a party can force someone else to reveal — is generally very broad, though there are some limits. A party may ask for facts about the case, for the identity of others who may know something about the case, for documents relating to the case, and for inspection of physical objects or property connected to the dispute. Discovery can be used to seek information not only from the other party, but also from people and businesses that aren’t involved in the legal proceedings.
There are four types of formal tools that are frequently used in financial discovery during divorce. They are:
- In a deposition, one party or that party’s lawyer conducts face-to-face questioning of the other party or a witness to the dispute. The person being questioned (the “deponent”) must answer under oath, and the answers are recorded for later use at trial. If the deponent cannot testify at trial, the questions and answers might be read to the jury as evidence. If the deponent does testify and gives different answers at trial from those he gave during the deposition, the questions and answers can be used to show the jury that the witness changed his story.
- Requests for production of evidence.In a request for production of evidence, one party asks the other for physical evidence related to the dispute. Requests for production are usually used to gather pertinent documents, such as contracts, employment files, billing records, or documents related to real estate. However, these requests can also be used to inspect physical objects or property — for example, in a dispute about whether a contractor properly repaired a homeowner’s roof, the contractor’s lawyer might ask to have a roofing expert inspect the work.
- Interrogatories are written questions one party sends to the other to be answered under oath. The answers can be used at trial in the same way as deposition answers — to challenge a party who changes her story later.
- Requests for admission.In a request for admission, one party asks the other party to admit, under oath, that certain facts are true or certain documents are genuine. These requests are generally used to save time and to narrow the issues that have to be proved at trial.
We work with our clients to identify and collect the financial data pertinent to the divorce. From the original data gathering we evaluate any key financial concerns related to divorce – such as income and deductions, living expenses, assets, and liabilities. This process will likely tip us to other information we will need to request.
Wellspring Advisors work with the attorney to compile complete and comprehensive document requests, interrogatories and depositions to insure no stone goes unturned and the right questions are asked to help level the playing field. Good financial discovery will give you the peace of mind that no assets were hidden. Knowledge is power in the financial negotiations of divorce and formal discovery may be the only way to gain the knowledge you need.
Can I deduct legal fees for divorce?
/in Divorce Financial Planning /by Justin ReckersMaybe. It depends on the reason you incurred the fees. You cannot deduct the basic legal fees for divorce or court filing costs. However, you can deduct any fees including legal fees that were paid for tax advice related to the divorce or to help you get taxable alimony or spousal support. These legal fees for divorce are allowable only to the extent that their total in any one year exceeds two percent of adjusted gross income. Wellspring Divorce Advisors fees may also qualify under these rules. You should ask your attorney to generate detailed billing showing the portion of the bill related to deductible items.
Check out this article from Divorce Taxation expert Julian Block for more details.
Consult your tax preparer before taking any actions that may have tax consequences.
What is financial discovery during divorce?
/in Divorce Financial Planning, General, High Net Worth Divorce /by Justin ReckersFinancial discovery is the fact finding/document gathering part of the divorce process. Financial discovery can be time consuming and may be the most expensive part of a divorce process for a wealthy family. Financial discovery will most likely happen over time. The amount of time depends on whether or not the parties are being cooperative. It is a process, not an event, and requires ongoing document requests until all necessary information is gathered.
For the most part, discovery takes place outside the courtroom, with parties exchanging written information and sitting through face-to-face questioning sessions (called “depositions”). However, if the parties can’t agree on what should be handed over in discovery, a judge may have to resolve the dispute.
The kind of information that a party can force someone else to reveal — is generally very broad, though there are some limits. A party may ask for facts about the case, for the identity of others who may know something about the case, for documents relating to the case, and for inspection of physical objects or property connected to the dispute. Discovery can be used to seek information not only from the other party, but also from people and businesses that aren’t involved in the legal proceedings.
There are four types of formal tools that are frequently used in financial discovery during divorce. They are:
We work with our clients to identify and collect the financial data pertinent to the divorce. From the original data gathering we evaluate any key financial concerns related to divorce – such as income and deductions, living expenses, assets, and liabilities. This process will likely tip us to other information we will need to request.
Wellspring Advisors work with the attorney to compile complete and comprehensive document requests, interrogatories and depositions to insure no stone goes unturned and the right questions are asked to help level the playing field. Good financial discovery will give you the peace of mind that no assets were hidden. Knowledge is power in the financial negotiations of divorce and formal discovery may be the only way to gain the knowledge you need.
What is no fault divorce and how does it affect my financial settlement?
/in California Divorce Dictionary, Divorce Financial Planning /by Justin ReckersNo Fault Divorce means that you are not required to provide proof your spouse was “at fault” or did something wrong, such as committing adultery, or being abusive to be granted a divorce. Every state in the US has adopted some form “no-fault” divorce laws. California was the first to do so in 1969 under then Governor Ronald Reagan. New York was the last to do so in 2010. The application of the no fault divorce terminology is not uniform from state to state since each state independently passed laws to enact it. Some states allow but do not require the proof of fault in a divorce filing while others don’t even allow a petitioner to claim any grounds for fault in a filing. Check with an attorney in your state to verify your state laws.
How can no-fault laws affect your financial settlement?
They don’t necessarily. You may still be permitted to show facts related to one parties actions as part of your case. Some states are known as “equitable distribution” states and allow a judge to take the conduct of parties during the marriage into account in dividing assets. Equitable does not mean equal. This means the court can divide assets based up on what it believes is FAIR and effectively penalize a party financially for their actions during marriage. Dissipation is one of the most common fault actions affecting an asset division in divorce. Dissipation, in loose terms, refers to the misappropriation of marital assets. Usually these allegations stem from drug use, pornography, gambling or expenses related to acts of infidelity.
If you believe dissipation to be an issue in your divorce we suggest you seek guidance of a certified divorce financial analyst at Wellspring Divorce Advisors to help you understand the cost/ benefit of making such an argument. These types of claims typically require significant forensic accounting to prove the flow of funds and who was in control of it and it may not be worth it to pursue the claim in light of the cost associated with doing so.
What is “vesting” and how does it affect my divorce?
/in Divorce Financial Planning, General, High Net Worth Divorce /by Justin ReckersVesting gives an employee rights to employer-provided assets over time, which gives the employee an incentive to perform well and remain with the company. The vesting schedule set up by the company determines when the employee acquires full ownership of the asset. Generally, non-forfeitable rights accrue based on how long the employee has worked there.
Read more: Vesting Definition | Investopedia https://www.investopedia.com/terms/v/vesting.asp#ixzz3kbDViTje
If an employee is vested it means that at least some of the retirement plan or stock options belongs to the employee and not the employer. This is the amount an employee is entitled to take when the employee leaves their employer. The portion that is vested comes from two sources:
How does vesting affect my asset division in divorce?
A benefit does not have to be vested to be considered an asset subject to division in your divorce but it does mean the funds may not be immediately available for you to spend. Wellspring Divorce Advisors will review your assets and make recommendations as to the true value of unvested assets and suggestions as to how to divide them. Unvested assets such as stock options, restricted stock units, pensions and other executive compensation must be handled carefully in legal agreements and long after the divorce is final. The agreements typically require the deferred division of these unvested assets meaning the employee spouse must maintain the benefits for their former spouse and the former spouse must be diligent in watching for vestings long after the divorce is finalized. Make sure you post-divorce financial advisor is competent in managing this ongoing entanglement with your former spouse
Are pension and other retirement plans considered marital assets and subject to division in divorce?
/in California Divorce Dictionary, Divorce Financial Planning, General, Post Divorce Financial Planning /by Justin ReckersYes, retirement plans are marital assets subject to division to the extent they were earned during the marriage. State laws differ on how to determine exactly what “earned during marriage” means so be sure to check with a local expert. In California the presumption is that any pension plans, 401K balances and other retirement accounts are community property and subject to division unless/until proven otherwise. If the retirement plan benefit was earned during marriage it will be divided.
In order to earn pension benefits a worker must be employed and participating in the plan.
In order to participate in a 401K plan the worker must make contributions to the plan by deferring wages from his or her regular paycheck.
Since both examples would require the participant to earn their benefit in one form or another, either time in the pension plan or contributions to the 401K, these earnings are considered community property or martial assets and will typically be divided 50/50 unless their are other extenuating circumstances or the parties agree otherwise.
Be careful though to make sure you are dividing apples with apples as retirement plans are pre-tax money where as other assets may have already been taxed. The difference in value between $100,000 pre-tax and $100,000 after tax could be $20,000 or even $50,000.